Rooted in faith. Here for our neighbors.(317) 908-8635
Humble Impressions

Serving our community since 2012

Good finds.
A greater purpose.

A thrift store just for you. Find something you love, save a little, and help support the work of Humble Love.

Find your storeGet to know us

Inspired by Jesus.
Everyone is welcome here.

Humble Impressions storefront sign with a cross and the words A Thrift Store Just For You.
Humble ImpressionsFaith in action.
Looking for food assistance?Humble Love · Mon, Wed & Fri · 2–5 p.m.
Plan your pantry visit

Come on in

Three places to find
your next favorite thing.

Used treasures and discounted retail finds.
Every store shares a heart for the community.

Madison Avenue

Indianapolis

5501 Madison Avenue

Across from Humble Love

Tuesday–Saturday11 a.m.–5 p.m.
Directions

Beech Grove

Albany Street

2509 Albany Street

Next to Dollar General and the liquor store

Tuesday–Saturday10 a.m.–5 p.m.
Directions

Taylorsville

U.S. 31

9950 U.S. 31

Taylorsville, Indiana

Tuesday–Saturday10 a.m.–5 p.m.
Directions

Planning a donation drop-off? Please visit during open hours. Accepted items vary by location—call ahead if you're unsure.

Our story

A little help can
change a life.

Humble Impressions' purple cloud design, cross, and A Thrift Store Just For You tagline.
A familiar name. A mission close to the heart.

For Rebecca Pardue, helping others began with knowing what it feels like to need help.

When difficult circumstances made it hard to afford clothes for her child, Rebecca found support through the church. That kindness, and the teachings of Jesus, stayed with her.

She founded Humble Impressions in 2012 with a desire to help others experience that same welcome and support. Today, the stores help people save money while supporting Humble Love's work in the community.

A place to feel welcome.
A way to care for one another.

  1. 2012Rebecca starts Humble Impressions.
  2. 2025The Madison Avenue store moves to 5501.
  3. TodayThree thrift stores support a shared mission.

The mission we support

Meet
Humble Love.

Bringing the love of Jesus to our community through practical care.

Humble Love is the charitable mission of Humble Impressions. The distribution center provides free food for neighbors in need, just across the street from our Madison Avenue thrift store.

Visit HumbleLove.org

Kindness keeps moving

Give what you can.
Help where you can.

Shopping with us and giving generously help support a mission rooted in the love of Jesus.

01 / Donate items

A new home for
something good.

We welcome donations in like-new condition. What we can accept varies by store, so please plan ahead and call if you're unsure.

Please bring donations during open hours only. Items that cannot be sold may be given away or discarded when necessary.

See locations & hours
02 / Support the mission

Let your generosity
reach a neighbor.

Financial gifts help support our community work. Make a gift through our donation page on Zeffy.

Donate online

Zeffy may invite you to add a separate, optional contribution to support its platform.

Questions about giving? Call (317) 908-8635.

Before you visit

A few helpful
answers.

Something else on your mind?
We're a phone call away.

What are the thrift-store hours?

Madison Avenue is open Tuesday–Saturday, 11 a.m.–5 p.m. Beech Grove and Taylorsville are open Tuesday–Saturday, 10 a.m.–5 p.m.

Find an address and directions.

What will I find in the stores?

We sell used items and discounted retail items. Visit your local store to see what is available.

When can I drop off donations?

During open hours only. We request items in like-new condition. Accepted items vary by location, so please call (317) 908-8635 ahead of time if you're unsure.

Items that cannot be sold may be given away or discarded when necessary.

What do I need to visit the food pantry?

Bring your ID and a smile. Humble Love is at 5520 Madison Avenue, Indianapolis, and distributes free food Monday, Wednesday, and Friday, 2–5 p.m.

Visits are currently once every two weeks, depending on supply. Call us with questions before your visit.

How can I make a financial gift?

Visit our donation page on Zeffy to support our community work.

Any extra contribution to Zeffy is optional. Questions about giving? Email us or call (317) 908-8635.

How are Humble Impressions and Humble Love connected?

Humble Impressions is the parent organization. Our three thrift stores help support Humble Love, our charitable mission bringing the love of Jesus to the community through food distribution and care.

Explore Humble Love's own website.

Did the Madison Avenue store move?

Yes. Our thrift store moved to 5501 Madison Avenue in 2025. Older listings may show 8224 Madison Avenue or nearby addresses connected with the original location.

Humble Love's distribution center is now across the street at 5520 Madison Avenue.

Let's stay connected

There's a person
here to help.

Questions about a store, a donation, or the pantry?
Give us a call or send an email.

(317) 908-8635Garydean_7@yahoo.com

Humble Impressions

How can we help?

Choose a topic or search our visitor information.

Our quick answers cover locations, hours, donations, and food-pantry visits.

Need to speak with us? Call (317) 908-8635 or email us.